Each term we have to do 'Tracking'. This involves giving each pupil a grade for attainment and one for effort. Due to a fool-proof system in the maths department the attainment part is easily dealt with. However the effort grade, or 'Behaviour for Learning' grade, is a little trickier.
I really do question how a teacher can accurately assess how hard someone has been trying. Okay you can have a good stab at it but when there's four grades - A, B, C, D (plus an X if you don't think the pupil has been in enough lessons to judge them) - to pick from there's a good chance you'll get it wrong on a good few occasions. It was easier before because we had a simpler A, B, C system.
This time though I think I've got it horrendously wrong. Plenty of form tutors have come to me querying grades their tutees have been given, including one where I have failed to give a girl in year seven a National Curriculum level, I would put it right but she doesn't actually have one. She's not even on the scale yet.
One form tutor said a pupil was upset I'd given him an X. He's not been in that many lessons so I did find it difficult to tell how hard he'd been working, that and I wanted to play with the new grade X.
My year tens were particularly upset over it. One girl was really put out that I hadn't given her an A and to be honest I was struggling to think why not. She even did an impression of Puss-in-boots from Shrek looking all sad. I'm a sucker for that sort of thing so got her to wait back at the end of the lesson so I could give her some Milky Way Magic Stars as compensation. An out-of-court settlement if you like.
In my form there's a girl who is pretty much perfect, unfortunately her art teacher gave her a B and she was quite down about it. From experience of my form producing posters for competitions I know she's not exactly Rembrant but she always gives it her best shot. I know 100% that she really deserves an A in art, even without having seen any of her work because she's that sort of kid. She's got the right attitude though and is determined to work even harder in art. Though I reckon it'll be difficult to change her teacher's view as we're terrible for forming an opinion and sticking with it despite new evidence to the contrary.
It all makes me think that the notion of grading our pupils in this way is absurd bordering on cruel. We need to have some method of highlighting if there are any issues but it doesn't make much difference if we give them an A and B. All it seems to achieve is to make them feel bad and me feel guilty.
Next time I'm just going to give them all As and be done with it.